Sunday, 25 July 2010

Reading Too Much into Toy Story 3

SPOILER WARNING: Do not read this until you've seen the film.

The third film in Pixar's Toy Story series is the most dogmatic to date. It's the story of mankind's relationship with God, and its position on how humans should relate to the almighty couldn't be clearer. The script may as well have been written by John Calvin himself.

God

The God in this film goes by the name of Andy, and at the beginning of the movie it's established that he is about to move on to universes new, leaving behind the realm he has ruled over up until now. AndyGod's problem is that his current universe is populated with toys that he has loved and cherished throughout his existence, and before he can leave he has to decide what to do with them. He has four choices: he can take them with him to his new domain; he can hand them over to a different god (so okay, maybe the script isn't as Calvinist as I said above); he can consign them to a worldly attic purgatory; or he can send them to Hell. He chooses the third option for all the toys except his favourite, Woody, with whom he is well-pleased.

Woody

Woody is a sanctimonious prick who spends his entire life reminding all his colleagues of AndyGod's greatness and infallibility and generally bossing people around. When AndyGod decides to send the rest of the toys to purgatory, Woody supports Him totally -- and we must assume that had AndyGod decided instead to send them to Hell, Woody would be quoting Romans 3:10 as justification and telling them to suck it up because the potter can do whatever he wants with his clay.

When, by mistake, the mother of AndyGod sets the toys on a path towards Hell, Woody rushes to save them. But why? Is it because he's concerned for his colleagues, or because the Law of his Lord has been interfered with? I think it's probably the latter, because Woody is a dick.

The Other Toys

When the toys realise that they're destined for Hell they (understandably) become angry and decide to reject AndyGod and go off to find other gods to serve. Woody remonstrates with them, telling them they should remain faithful and that it was all a mistake; but under the leadership of the Female Temptress Jesse, the others won't listen to him. As far as they're concerned whether their deity has abandoned them to Hell or Purgatory makes little difference; the issue is that they've been abandoned, while Woody has not.

When they all arrive in a kind of Paradise for toys, a place where they will be played with all day long (which after all, is what they were designed for), Woody is still griping and insisting that they return to AndyGod's house and get themselves up into Attic Purgatory where they belong, while he swans off to whatever exciting new place AndyGod is going to. The other Toys again ignore him, looking forward to a new life of hedonism...

And this, of course, proves to be their downfall.

Lotso Bear

The paradise they think they have discovered is in fact ruled by an atheist; an evil, strawberry-smelling bear who has rejected all gods and has set himself up as a mortal god on earth. He's a pink furry Stalin (I think they even refer to him as "Uncle" at one point). The message is clear: if you reject the god that owns you, you have only yourself to blame if you end up being tortured in a totalitarian gulag.

The film could have ended here, but audiences may have been left with a view of God as cold and unconcerned with his universe, so the story carries on. Woody continues his righteous quest to be reunited with his Master, but then he gets distracted by feelings of compassion for his colleagues. Foolishly, he tries to help them, not realising that by attempting to interfere with destiny he's only going to make things worse.

His efforts lead the toys to the very edge of Hell, which they only escape by means of a Ludicrum Ex Machina. The atheist Lotso, of course, who has by now proved his evil atheist character beyond a doubt, is not so fortunate and is consigned to an eternal punishment direct from the mind of Dante.

Once the atheist villain has been disposed of the film can end nicely with the redemption of not only foolish Woody and the ungrateful toys but also AndyGod, who is finally shown indulging his merciful side.

And we can all walk out of the cinema saying "Ah, see? God is great after all. And blimey those 3D specs are uncomfortable, hope that fad burns itself out ASAFP."

18 comments:

HannahClaire said...

love love love this!!!!! :)

Fat Roland said...

My brain hurts.

Maxim said...

Also available in 2D.

weja said...

but the alientoys are saved as well, even after years of serving their lordandmaster THE POTATO? EXPLAIN V:

Anna said...

Woody is undoubtedly a proselytising chump; he's converted toys that were in claw machines, toys that were collectables, toys that... thought they were space rangers...

Yeah, what's that about? Is Buzz's tendency to believe his backstory a dig at Scientology?

And why was Bo lost? What did she do wrong? How can I avoid the wrath (and / or disinterest) of the AndyGod? :( Answers plz.

魏智偉魏智偉 said...

來打聲招呼-大家好!!!............................................................

rewboss said...

Hah! You know nothing! Toy Story is part of Paul the Octopus's plan to spread filthy Western superstitious propaganda!

Jolie Moon said...

WTF??? You should put a spoiler alert,dammit! ha ha j/k. Great post. I imagine this is what you lay awake at night thinking about. It certainly makes a little sense. And I imagine it doesn't end with toy story. the entire pixar/ animation world must be reviewed.

允黃淑 said...

來幫忙你衝人氣~順便留言支持你 ............................................................

李亦陳宏堯茵 said...

第一忠誠,第二勤奮,第三專心工作。......................................................

王辛江淑萍康 said...

一個人的價值,應該看他貢獻了什麼,而不是他取得了什麼.................................................................

偉曹琬 said...

唯有穿鞋的人,才知道鞋的哪一處擠腳......................................................................

偉曹琬 said...

看著你的BLOG 好多朋友都回應 真厲害..................................................

琬群學葉安高 said...

絕不要羞於承認自己不知道的事。..................................................

淑君韓淑君韓淑君韓 said...

感謝大大的無私分享 讓小弟獲益良多 終於知道網上還有這麼多的好東西≧▽≦"
............................................................

怡靜怡靜怡靜怡雯 said...

路過留言支持~~~............................................................

Rachel Virago said...

Are you SURE you didn't write the script Mike?

Many thanks for this it saves me from watching it until eventually it will be forced on me by some stoned acquaintance who has downloaded it to their laptop and thinks it's "deep on many levels" just after I have accepted their offer to stop over on their sofa because I am nearly as mashed as them.

If they fall asleep before me I will then fast forward and agree next morning over a full English that it was brilliant and use your synopsis as cover if they get picky.

Jil Wrinkle said...

Fabulous thinking, that.